High Court gives important judgment on gambling operators’ duty of care
The High Court (Swift J) has handed down judgment in Ashton and others v TSE Malta LP [2026] EWHC 2935 (KB), one of The Lawyer’s Top 20 Cases of 2026. The judgment provides important guidance on the circumstances in which a gambling operator owes a duty of care in negligence to prevent psychiatric injury. In dismissing the claim, Swift J held that a duty only arises in respect of foreseeable psychiatric injury and that psychiatric injury would likely only be foreseeable where the operator is either on notice (i) of a diagnosis of gambling disorder or (ii) that the customer’s behaviour was so extreme as to demonstrate a total lack of control.
The proceedings arose from the tragic death of Luke Ashton in April 2021. His family brought a negligence claim against TSE Malta LP alleging that failures to intervene in his gambling had exacerbated gambling disorder and contributed to his death.
The Claimants argued that the Court should recognise a wider duty of care than had been held to exist in previous authorities, which had consistently rejected a general duty of care owed by gambling operators to their customers. Swift J rejected this submission emphasising the difficulties operators face in identifying customers at risk of harm.
The judge also clarified the relationship between regulatory obligations imposed on gambling operators and duties at common law. The Claimants had submitted that the regulatory framework provided a basis for finding that a duty of care at common law arose, alternatively, that the standard of care at common law reflected the regulatory obligations. In rejecting this submission, Swift J explained that the regulator was concerned with a much wider category of harm than any suggested duty at common law, that Parliament had distinguished between a breach of regulatory duty and civil liability by s. 24(8) of the Gambling Act 2005, that the regulatory framework was insufficiently precise to be applied to civil claims, and warned that the courts must not usurp the regulator’s role. He also emphasised the importance of personal autonomy at common law.
The claim was dismissed because the evidence did not establish that Mr Ashton suffered from gambling disorder and the requirement of foreseeability was not met. The Court did not need to determine causation or contributory fault.
James Potts and Viktoria Winzer, led by Jonathan Hough KC of 4 New Square and instructed by Alan Owens of Keystone Law, acted for the successful Defendant.
Read the judgment here.





