Hefin Rees KC secures landmark Court of Appeal ruling on procedural unfairness in Morjaria v Mirza
On 20 November 2026, the Court of Appeal handed down judgment in Morjaria v Mirza after a 4-day appeal (concerning 16 appeal and cross-appeal grounds) following an 8-week trial (over 30 sitting days) between January and March 2025. The underlying proceedings included claims in deceit, breach of fiduciary duty, knowing receipt, conspiracy, breach of contract and unjust enrichment and a counterclaim in the tort of abuse of process.
The central issue on the appeal was whether the trial had been tainted by procedural unfairness (Ground 11). The Court of Appeal decided unanimously that the conduct complained of did render the trial unfair. The Court found that the judge intervened far too much during the course of evidence throughout the trial, that his interventions were of the character of cross-examination, were generally not made at a convenient point, such as when a line of questioning had been finished, and were not, as the Respondents suggested, directed merely at ensuring efficient case management. The Court also concluded that the Judge at times conducted a quasi-inquisitorial hearing, did not remain “aloof from the trial” and had his own ideas that he apparently wanted to test by questioning the witnesses. Accordingly, subject to certain exceptions, the Court ordered a re-trial. Although it is understood that this will be one of the largest re-trials ever ordered, the Court of Appeal stated that “no different conclusion can arise as to the legal effect of an unfair long and expensive trial as compared with a short and cheaper trial, provided always that the trial as a whole is found to be unfair”.
The Court also gave judgment on the ambit of the tort of abuse of process (Ground 1). The Court of Appeal concluded that as it stands, the tort of abuse of process is limited to civil proceedings and that it was not (despite the Privy Council seeing fit in the Sagicor appeal to advise that the tort of malicious prosecution applies to civil cases) for the Court of Appeal to “take what might be viewed as a mirror image step by extending the tort of abuse of process to criminal proceedings”.
3VB’s Hefin Rees KC, leading Jack Fletcher and Michael Campbell of 4 Stone Buildings, acted for the successful Appellants, instructed by Noble Solicitors.
The judgment is available to read here.





